Turbocharge your tax bill: Unleash cost segregation’s hidden power for real estate riches

Target Audience: Commercial Real Estate Professionals; Active short-term rental owners; Passive renters with other passive income

---

Legal Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is general in nature and is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended to be, nor should it be construed as, nor does it constitute tax, legal, accounting, or professional advice. Chapman CPA Services, PLLC disclaims any liability for any loss or damage resulting from the use of this information. Always consult with a qualified CPA or tax professional regarding your specific circumstances. Refer to website Terms & Conditions for full disclaimer.

---

Executive Summary

Cost segregation is a strategic tax planning tool that carves up the cost of real estate (normally depreciated over 27.5 years for standard residential or 39 years for nonresidential buildings) and break it into shorter-lived asset classes that have shorter useful lives —such as personal property (5-7 years) and land improvements (15 years).

Pros: You can receive higher, accelerated depreciation deductions in near-term years, which front-loads tax savings and boosts near-term cash flows. Deductions can increase even further if using bonus depreciation (which is allowable for assets with useful life <20 years).

Risks: Asset segregation converts part of your 1250 assets (real property) into 1245 assets (personal property) which will introduce a few nuances to consider.

1. Passive activity loss limitations - Net losses from rental real estate, which may come as a result of the accelerated depreciation deductions on 1245 personal property, will have restricted use under IRC 469 unless you qualify as a real estate professional (REP) with material participation in the activity. Otherwise, these losses can only offset passive incomes (e.g. from other rentals or other passive income) and cannot shelter ordinary income (e.g. wages). Any excess will have to be suspended and carried forward, potentially negating the benefit of cost segregation.

2. Depreciation recapture upon sale - When selling the property, the accelerated depreciation benefits are clawed back, with 1245 assets being taxed at ordinary income rate (up to 37%) while 1250 assets (had you not segregated costs) are taxed at an unrecaptured rate of 25%. This, however, can be deferred through 1031 exchanges if executed properly.

As a CPA and tax advisor, the key is to balance immediate benefits with long-term implications. It is important to ensure compliance via detailed studies, and leverage exceptions like the $25,000 active participation allowance, and consider bonus depreciation options for qualified properties to optimize outcomes. 

Done right, it can defer taxes significantly.

If mishandled, it risks an audit from the IRS, as well as the potential for penalties and other compliance headaches.

Summary of Impacts Pre-/Post-Segregation

Helpful Resource:

IRS’s Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide

---

Dive Deeper

Navigating the Tax Implications of Cost Segregation: A CPA’s Guide to Strategic Planning

Cost segregation isn’t just a depreciation accelerator—it’s a powerful lever for tax planning that demands careful consideration of your overall portfolio, participation level, and exit strategy. By reallocating a building’s purchase or construction costs from long-lived real property to shorter-lived components like fixtures, HVAC elements, or landscaping, you can claim larger deductions upfront, potentially saving thousands in taxes annually. 

But the IRS scrutinizes these studies closely, and the interplay with passive activity rules, material participation, and recapture can make or break its value. Let’s break it down step by step, focusing on what you need to know for proactive planning.

The Core Benefit: Accelerated Depreciation and Cash Flow Boost

At its heart, a cost segregation study uses engineering analysis to classify assets per IRS guidelines, such as Revenue Procedure 87-56, which outlines recovery periods for everything from 5-year office furniture to 15-year parking lots. For a $1 million commercial building, a typical study might reallocate 20-40% to shorter lives, enabling methods like 200% declining balance over 5-7 years instead of straight-line over 39 years. This isn’t theoretical: it can generate immediate deductions of 20-30% of the building’s cost in year one, especially when paired with bonus depreciation—100% depreciation for qualified property placed in service 2025+.

From a planning perspective, this works well for high-income clients in peak earning years, allowing them to defer taxes to lower-rate future periods. However, it’s most effective for properties held 5-10+ years as shorter holds amplify recapture risks, while longer holds dilute the time value of accelerated deductions. 

When you do decide to do a cost segregation analysis, always be sure to reconcile the study back to actual costs via blueprints or appraisals to withstand audits. The IRS’s Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide stresses reliance on detailed engineering over rough estimates or non-engineering analysis/background.

Passive Activity Losses: The Gatekeeper for Deduction Utilization

Rental real estate is presumptively passive under IRC Section 469, meaning losses—including turbocharged depreciation from segregation—can only offset passive income. It cannot be used to offset wages or portfolio gains. Suspended losses from not having enough passive income will carry forward indefinitely, but they’re useless until you generate passive income or dispose of the property. For many investors, this caps the strategy’s appeal unless you unlock exceptions to this rule.

Exception 1: The $25,000 active participation allowance is a low bar: if you own at least 10% and make key decisions (e.g., approving tenants), you can deduct up to $25,000 passive losses against non-passive income (i.e. ordinary wages), phasing out above $100,000 modified AGI. It is ideal for modest portfolios but won’t cover large segregation-driven losses.

Exception 2: Short-term rentals (average stay ≤7 days) can sidestep passive status entirely if you provide significant services, turning deductions active. So if you rent AND manage an Airbnb, then you might want to consider the impacts both short term and long term, as this may be an option for you.

Exception 3: Material Participation and Real Estate Professional Status: Your Ticket to Full Deductibility

The third way to avoid the passive loss activity limitations, and fully harness segregation benefits (i.e. use net loss to offset nonpassive income), is to qualify as a Real Estate professional (REP). To qualify you will need to meet the following requirements:

• >750 hours total work in real property trades or businesses per year, per taxpayer, with material participation per rental.

  • It does not count if you are an employee of a company, unless you own at least 5% of that company.

• >50% of your personal services/work time must be is in real estate (development, management, etc.).

  • If you work full time in a non-real estate job, then try to add real property activities on top, you will not qualify, because most of your time working is in your primary job.

• Material participation in the activity with the loss

  • You must materially participate in the rental activity, which can be met by one of the following:

    • >500 hours spent in the rental activities creating the net loss

    • >100 hours AND more than anyone else

    • Substantially all hours worked on the rental activity

  • If you hire a property manager to manage the property, it will be harder to meet the material participation requirements.

To help you prove the above, make sure that you diligently maintain a hours log to show you met the requirements. You may need to maintain a log of time that others spent also, if you are going to prove that you spent more hours than anyone else.

REP status transforms your passive losses into active deductions, letting segregation deductions shelter W-2 income.  Many advise grouping rentals on Schedule E for simplicity, but elect aggregation only if it aligns with REP goals.

Depreciation Recapture: The Inevitable Tax Bill on Exit (Sale)

What is the flip side? If you sell the property later on, you will trigger "depreciation recapture", which will treat all previously deducted depreciation as gain income, up to the sale price.  The tax rate on this recapture will differ based on its asset classification.

• Section 1245 property: Segregated personal property (Section 1245 assets) will be recaptured taxed at ordinary income rates (up to 37%). This is referred to as "Depreciation recapture", since it is recaptured at ordinary tax rates.

• Section 1250 property: The building shell (Section 1250) will be recaptured and taxed at preferential 25% tax rate. This is considered "unrecaptured Section 1250 gain" since it is being recaptured at 25% which could be lower than ordinary tax rates, and therefore not full recaptured.

Any additional gain above the original purchase price (think appreciated property values), will be taxed as either a long-term capital gain if held > 1 year (taxed at 0%/15%/20% rates), else it will be considered a short-term capital gain taxed at ordinary income rates up to 37%.

Piecing it together: Say you do a cost segregation and 20% of your property value is 5-7 year property, you can take the depreciation all in year 1 through bonus depreciation or over 5-7 years through MACRS. This accelerates your tax benefit in those years. But if you sell in year 7, you have now accelerated a tax hit as that 5-year asset has been fully depreciated and will have 100% of its recapture value being taxes as ordinary income, whereas it would have been recaptured at 25% (if at all) had you not claimed cost segregation. This could be favorable or unfavorable, depending on your ordinary tax rates and other incomes to offset it. You could always defer the tax hit by doing a 1031 exchange, but make sure you meet all of the requirements to do so. Proper planning with a CPA or other qualified professional will be key in making sure the impacts work for you.

Tax Strategies to Consider - i.e. How to become the the Superhero of Cost Segregation!

• Cost Segregation Study

  • Reclassify percentage of building cost into 5-7 year or 15 year asset classes, eligible for immediate or accelerated depreciation

  • Perform in high-income years when the deductions matter the most.

• Ability to meet material participation and REP status

  • Turn passive income/losses into non-passive income/losses, offsetting your ordinary income

• Claim $25k active participation allowance

  • If actively participate, and MAGI between under $100k (with limited benefit up to $150k) then you can offset some losses against ordinary income.

• Short-term (<7 days - i.e. Airbnb, VRBO) vs long-term average rental lengths

  • Turn passive income/losses into active income/losses, offsetting your ordinary income

• 1031 like-kind Exchanges at sale

  • Defers 100% of capital gains, all 1245 depreciation recapture (including bonus), and carries over suspended passive losses to the replacement property, to be on hold until you sell the replacement property.

• Partial disposition for property improvement and additional depreciation

  • Partial dispositions (e.g., replace roof, HVAC, windows, flooring, etc.) do not trigger depreciation recapture. When you replace a major component and make the partial disposition election, you can immediately write off and deduct any remaining depreciation for that property, and begin recognizing depreciation on the new property (over time or immediately ). You also permanently remove depreciation recapture for that written-off property, though you will incur it again on the new property.

• Reinvest sale proceeds into Opportunity Zone Investment Fund(s)

  • Option until 12/31/2026, you can roll your gains and recaptures into an OZI fund within 180 days to defer all tax impacts. Holding for 10+ years can potentially provide for a step- up in basis to fair market value. There is a risk that regulations could change, which could impact the benefits 10 years down the road.

• Self-Rental Grouping election

  • This can be helpful when you own the building that your operating business rents from. You place that building into an LLC, then lease back to your business, which is good for asset protection. However, as these are separate businesses you now have the self-rental business (passive income/losses) and the operating business (non-passive). So, if you do not do a grouping election, you cannot deduct the passive losses (that you worked hard to get through cost segregation) against the non-passive income - thus trapping the deductions as passive losses.

  • If you miss this election, you cannot fix/amend in a subsequent year - it must be on the original return.

  • To claim you check a box in the tax software to group the activities, which is allowed under the treasury regulations, if you are a single economic unit based on common ownership, control and interdependence.

  • Do the election, and your passive losses can offset non-passive income due to the grouping. If you miss it, then your deductions will be suspended and become unusable until you have passive income to offset or until you sell the property.

• Suspended PALs at time of disposition

  • If you fully dispose of as asset that has remaining suspended PALs, there is a chance these can net against both passive and non passive income in the year of sale.

• Generational wealth - achieve step-up in basis by holding until death

  • Heir receive the property and reset its basis to the fair-market-value, permanently eliminating all built-in gains and depreciation recapture.

    
    

Planning Thoughts to Consider

• Cost segregation will usually best suit properties with valuation above $500,000 with 20%+ segregable costs.

• You may not see the benefits if passive limits will offset the benefits without REP status, or if you plan on holding for a short period of time (0-3 years). 

• You will need to file Form 3115 to claim the cost segregation, and to claim retroactive changes, capturing Section 481(a) depreciation catch-ups. 

• Engage qualified engineers. Contingency fees can raise red flags. Integrate with Section 179 and bonus depreciation for largest tax impacts.

• Model out your scenarios with a CPA or other qualified tax professional—The NPV often favors segregation despite the 25% sting of recapture.

  
  

Under the right circumstances cost segregation is a great tax-efficient growth strategy, but success hinges on your participation profile and horizon. Reach out and book a consultation to discuss more!

FREE Consultation

30min

Book Now

---

Frequently Asked Questions:

Q: What do you do if you have already taken depreciation?

The benefits can still apply to you, and the good news is that you do not have to amend ANY prior returns! Instead, you will file Form 3115 (Change in Accounting Method) wit your current-year ta return to make a "catch-up" adjustment under IRC 481(a). The entire amount of missed depreciation from the date the property was placed into service through the year of change will be deducted in the current year as a single negative 481(a) adjustment. Combined with bonus depreciation, this can create a massive one-year windfall without restating prior years.

Q: Who can do a perform cost segregation analysis? Can I perform myself?

In order for the study to hold up in an IRS examination/audit, only a qualified engineer/construction expert should perform the study. Without the credentials, the study will almost always be disallowed by the IRS if challenged.

Q: Can I undo the cost segregation once we have split the assets?

No - once you have reclassified assets, the shorter lives and accelerated/bonus depreciation are locked in and a wholesale reversal is not an option. Any attempt to try to reverse this would cause IRS attention, would most likely not be approved, and would trigger immediate income inclusion of the 481(a) adjustment.

Q: How do you claim this segregation

You will need to file Form 3115 to claim the cost segregation, and to claim any retroactive changes, capturing Section 481(a) depreciation catch-ups. Make sure to work with a CPA or qualified tax specialist to claim the adjustment correctly.

Q: What are the accounting implications of doing a cost segregation?

From a Tax perspective, depreciation will be dramatically accelerated for the new 1245 property. Under GAAP/IFRS financial accounting, book depreciation expense and accelerated depreciation will remain unchanged from the previous methodology. This will likely cause a larger book-tax difference and create a permanent M-3 adjustment, increasing or decreasing the current tax benefit/liability as needed.

Q: Can I do cost segregation on my personal property/residence too?

No - Since personal residences are not depreciable assets under IRS rules, this would only apply to personal property used in a trade/business or for producing income, like rentals. If your home is later converted into a rental and ceases from being your personal residence, then YES, at that time you could do so. Work with a CPA to determine if the benefits would be meaningful for your situation.

Q: Can I do cost segregation on my rental property?

Yes - You can absolutely perform cost segregation on a rental property, whether it be residential or commercial. Work with a CPA to maximize the impacts of doing a cost segregation analysis.

Q: What kind of property can be segregated out and counted as 1245 assets?

According to IRC 1245, these assets must be tangible personal property or land improvements, not structural components under IRC 1250. Examples can include (carpet, flooring, decorative lighting, cabinetry, appliances, window treatments, furniture, fixtures, sidewalks, fencing, sprinklers, security systems, specialty plumbing/HVAC, removable decorative elements, etc.).

Q: What happens to the cost segregation benefit if I subsequently sell the building in a 1031 exchange?

When you exchange the entire building (real property) via §1031, the affixed §1245 components (e.g., fixtures from cost segregation) are treated as real property under final IRS regulations, deferring gain and §1245 recapture—provided the replacement property has equal or greater value in similar components.  Standalone personal property exchanges aren’t allowed post-TCJA, but bundled in a building, they qualify without triggering immediate taxes.